• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Autocracy Analyst
  • Articles
  • Videos
  • About Us

Hungarian Public Foundation Rejects NGO Application for EU Funding over Unlawful Foreign Agent Law

September 30, 2020 by takacsistvangabor

Tweet

In June, the highest court in the European Union ruled that Hungary’s Foreign Agent Law requiring NGOs with foreign funding to self-identify and disclose their donors was unlawful. A few months later, a Hungarian public foundation operated by the government denied Power of Humanity Foundation, a human rights education NGO, EU funding over noncompliance with the same law. The NGO is asking the European Commission to investigate. 

Law No LXXVI of 2017 – dubbed the Hungarian foreign agent law – requires Hungarian NGOs receiving at least 22,000 Euros a year from outside of Hungary to declare themselves as foreign-funded organizations on a public website created by the Ministry of Human Resources. A group of NGOs, including the Power of Humanity Foundation, together with the Rights Reporter Foundation (the NGO operating the Autocracy Analyst blog) refused to comply with this law and filed a lawsuit at the European Court of Justice against the government. In it, they argued that he law was not intended to improve transparency, but to stigmatise NGOs receiving foreign funding, many of whom have previously been targeted by the hate-propaganda of the government. 

In June of this year, the European Court of Justice found that the Hungarian law was indeed unlawful.

The ruling caused an uproar in government circles, and the Court was accused of being manipulated by George Soros, a philanthropist who has been frequently targeted by government propaganda in Hungary. Prime Minister Viktor Orbán accused NGOs funded by Open Society Foundations, Soros’s grantmaking organization of doing the bidding of foreign powers, and hinted at Soros’s influence over the European Court of Justice. Power for Humanity is one of the Hungarian OSF grantees and was previously harshly criticised by the pro-government media. 

Two months later, Tempus, a public foundation established by the Hungarian government to distribute international funding, rejected an EU grant application from the Power of Humanity Foundation (PHF, Emberség Erejével Alapítvány,) over noncompliance with the same law. Although the Tempus acknowledged that PHF’s application reached their eligibility threshold to receive the Erasmus+ grant they applied for, they rejected the application because the NGO did not comply with the requirement to self-identify as a foreign-funded organization.

Our video features a protest against the anti-NGO law in 2017

We were shocked to learn that a grant established to promote European values was denied to us because we refused to comply with regulations that go against the same EU values.

Zoltán Mester, the Power of Humanity Foundation

“To declare ourselves as foreign funded NGOs was out of the question for us,”  says Zoltán Mester, PHF’s communications coordinator. “We decided to boycott this law as an act of civil disobedience because we respect European values and human rights unconditionally.” PHF would have used the grant was to translate and adapte their award-winning DEMO citizenship simulator to the languages and legal and cultural contexts of other countries, explains Mester to Autocracy Analyst. “DEMO is a strategic board game that excitingly develops students’ social and civic competencies. Players face various social problems, the possible solutions present a wide range of civic activity.” 

PHF disputed the decision in a letter to Tempus, and pointed out that the legal provisions concerned have been found to be in violation of EU law and as such, they are inapplicable in member states. Therefore the request to make a declaration is unlawful, and PHF’s refusal to do so is justified. In its response Tempus informed them that their Board of Trustees decided “that only organisations operating lawfully, observing domestic law could receive funding.” The Power of Humanity Foundation has sent a letter to the European Commission in protest, asking it to investigate the case and ensure that the primacy of EU law is to be upheld.

Péter Sárosi

Executive Director of the Rights Reporter Foundation.

He is a historian, a human rights activist and drug policy expert, the founder and editor of the Drugreporter website since 2004, a documentary film maker and blogger. He has been working for the Hungarian Civil Liberties Union (HCLU) for more than 10 years. Now he leads the Rights Reporter Foundation.

    Photo: Power of Humanity Foundation
    Illustration by István Gábor Takács

    Filed Under: Autocracy Analyst

    Primary Sidebar

    This blog provides you English news updates, articles, and videos about rising authoritarian rule in Hungary. Read more about us!

    More from the Autocracy Analyst

    Orbán Strikes Civil Society Again

    July 6, 2021 By takacsistvangabor

    The Hungarian government has adopted new rules designed to intimidate Hungarian NGOs and people who donate money to them. With the space for civil society in Hungary rapidly shrinking, the support and solidarity of the international community is needed more than ever.

    Outsourcing Autocracy: The Rise of the Hungarian Deep State

    April 28, 2021 By takacsistvangabor

    The right-wing authoritarian government of Hungary decided to give away billions of Euros in public funds to private foundations controlled by a small political-economic elite. Thereby effectively forming a shadow government that can continue to rule the country, regardless of the results of the parliamentary elections.     

    The Deep Moral Crisis of the Hungarian Establishment

    December 4, 2020 By takacsistvangabor

    The tale of the anti-gay MEP arrested at a gay sex party is not the first, and probably won’t be the last in the long line of scandals that reveal the deep moral crisis of the Hungarian elite. But will it be enough to shake Orban’s system? On a cold Friday night at the end […]

    “Political Pressure is Often Exercised through Business Means” Interview with Investigative Journalists Blanka Zöldi and András Pethő

    November 19, 2020 By Péter Sárosi

    Direkt36 is a Budapest-based investigative journalism center that follows the Pro Publica model of in-depth research and partnership-based distribution to maximize readership. They interpret accountability broadly; they believe in the responsibility to show the public how decisions are made, and to show who really holds the power. András Pethő co-founded Direkt36 with Gergely Sáling and Balázs […]

    What Freedom-Loving Hungarians Expect from a Biden Presidency

    November 1, 2020 By Péter Sárosi

    Joe Biden is favored to win the presidency in the upcoming U.S. elections. He has condemned the Hungarian prime minister and praised “freedom-loving Hungarians.” What would his presidency mean for pro-democracy activists in practice? We interviewed human rights leaders on the ground, who told us about their perceptions of U.S. foreign policy in Hungary, what changed during the Trump era, and what a good relationship with U.S. diplomacy means to them.

    OUR MISSION

    "The Rights Reporter Foundation (RRF) is a non-profit organisation founded by Hungarian activists to advocate for the human rights of vulnerable populations. Our vision is of a society where policies affecting vulnerable communities are evidence-informed and respect human rights, as well as developed and implemented with the meaningful involvement of these communities."

    E-mail Newsletter

    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    • Twitter
    Support us now!

    Search

    Tags

    Explainer

    Footer

    RIGHTS REPORTER FOUNDATION

    Hungary, 1032 Budapest
    San Marco Street 70.
    Email: rightsreporter@rightsreporter.net

    OUR OTHER WEBSITES:

    The Rights Reporter Foundation

    Drugreporter

    Room for Change Campaign

    Room in the 8th District Campaign

    A Day in the Life movie website

    Search

    Tags

    Explainer

    Autocracy Analyst